Thursday, 13 December 2018

NOTES ON PRIVILEGE

there is something in social/political/economic systems that enshrines privilege. this quality of inequity has various roots in surviving custom and by conscious design and is ubiquitous. why is that? is it inherent in the human animal and therefore inevitable? i don’t know the answer. i have tried to observe not only humans but also other animals of our planet, without conclusive results, but tentatively i would have to say that i think such a condition is most likely evolutionarily designed, that it is rooted in the individual and species’ common urge to survive and procreate.
ideas, like individuals, also compete. one idea that seems to run against the current is the idea of limiting ideas that compete with present mores. much effort is given to thwarting new thought by those who administer and profit from present assumptions and practices. this seemingly contrary behavior may endure because it promotes stability at the expense of adaptability, that change is in itself dangerous and needs to be controlled for the safety of the species. or it might endure simply because some are selfish and concerned more with their own survival, comfort and pleasure than their society in total. in my experience i would have to say the latter reason is supported by more evidence, though even if true it may have ineluctably produced increased fitness.

whether anything can be done to effectively make cooperation, more than competition, a fundamental first principle in the minds of the peoples of earth i am not sure, though i do think that, to the degree humans have survived to dominate the planet, that domination is not largely the result of competition, unbridled or otherwise, but owes its success much more to the continuing (and growing) influence of cooperation.



Sunday, 14 October 2018

YES, EVOLUTION HAS AN ARROW

when defending egregious behavior among the humans, many resort to the claim that it is only human nature that men (especially men) do this or that, (like making war and other intimidation displays) as though somehow so-called human nature is not evolving continually like every other phenomenon in the universe, that using the past to justify the abysmal present is normal and correct.

it is not. it would be better for individuals, society and the prospects of both if we would try to consult the near future, with its obvious known challenges, in order to assess what behavior is likely to be the most useful, or at least the least harmful, in the present moment.

HALF A TWO-BIT PHILOSOPHY

here is one bit of two-bit philosophy for you:

i have watched over the years some people who are hypercritical of others, even and maybe especially their so-called friends. it strikes me that underlying this depressing behavior it is quite likely they are primarily and mainly critical of themselves.

these opinions of others are almost always framed around actions and motivations, and condemnation is justification for not liking or respecting them.

it took me many years to understand that it is quite possible to love people while not loving all the things they do.

i think that might be the same for oneself. the two cases are probably more inextricably linked than the hypercritical among us understand.

anyway, it's worth a try.

Friday, 28 September 2018

HEARING MR KAVANAUGH

hearing mr kavanaugh testify yesterday afternoon was a revelation. he sounded angry, childish, petulant, beligerent, uncomposed, unthoughtful, and worst of all, entitled. i suspect that is what he is.

those qualities may resonate with mr trump and people like him — including much of the republican old guard, who are themselves largely privileged men used to their eminence, but they are not going to resonate with the majority of americans because those are not the qualities america needs in its elected official representatives of the people, for starters, and they are certainly not the qualities needed to serve those same people on the supreme court, which is the ultimate judicial arbiter and safeguarder of american rights, both collective and individual.

Saturday, 8 September 2018

HUMILITY NOW

mr pinker, in his poorly titled Enlightenment Now, has based his optimism on some dubious assumptions, the principal one being that mankind and the earth will both be well-served by humans becoming about ninety percent urban and that is where we are heading.

in this work there are a number of unsupported declarative sentences about the future (example: the sun will expand in a billion years). this book is better (but not unarguably better) at portraying the past, but in conceiving of the earth and humanity as a single economic system (though he is not an economist) and assuming the future is inevitable, he has polluted the entire roster of conclusions and remedies that might have made a book of this scope useful. real solutions lie elsewhere:
reducing the production of useless things to satisfy aggrandizing humans' consumption of both energy and material; reducing runaway expectation in favor of more thoughtful lives, more peaceful lives; reducing on a personal level one's own carbon footprint (something you can do alone without the need of meetings and endless talk). 

the problems are not technological. humans are great at technology. when humans fail, the failure is ultimately one of intent, of understanding what life is; the errors are philosophical and the remedies can be found in scientific enquiry.

nuclear powerplants cannot fix this planet. everyone living in cities, removed from the natural world, cannot secure this planet or its people a future, at least not a future free of catastrophe. we should not blithely assume that large-scale problems will abate spontaneously, that markets somehow have a magic quality of super-intelligence. we need a different kind of attitude, a different more inquisitive, more open and patient response to our self-created problems. we need, not to tell the earth what we will do, more to ask the earth what we should do. and that inquiry, that is the real role of science, which predates and postdates the enlightenment with its emphasis on humanism. unless humanism is widened to include all life — something that was not done during the enlightenment and is not yet done today — it is itself just another form of blindness. 

the most satisfying part of this book is the section on science. the least satisfying part is the section on the environment. mr. pinker wants us to feel good about doing nothing, or doing the wrong things because they are generated spontaneously without informed guidance. if one really internalizes the assumptions of Enlightenment Now — that life on earth is all about humans — we are dooming all life here to oblivion. you could argue that one little nuclear picnic or a fatally polluted planet in the cosmos is a trifle of no importance on the grand scale of events, but i don't think that will comfort many in their quest for reasons to remain optimistic in the face of existential threats.

Wednesday, 22 August 2018

LITTLE THINGS AND BIG THINGS

this morning i am smiling because it has just occurred to me that i can put some gel insoles in my slippers, slippers i wear around the cabin during the morning and evening — which cabin has a cement floor and may not be the best for my ageing knees. 

writing at my desk, making notes wherever i am during the day, i spend time trying to wrestle the big ideas to the ground (though i don't waste much time on the questions that can never be answered) and i consider it worthy of my time, but the things i do that cheer me in the moment are more the little things — the things that improve and perfect my personal life. that is the best antidote i have found for the general malaise of our changing times. that is the balance i need in order to confront the big ones, which so often seem, sadly, to be retrograde.

Thursday, 12 July 2018

I'M ALRIGHT, JACK — NOT GOOD ENOUGH

there was a time when private capital was the fastest way forward at the scale of nations (though one can point to some very fast, if brutal, forward leaps made in the early twentieth century by communism) but at the moment the effects of capitalism on societies at large represent a retarding force for progress. the system was never meant to produce equality — it is founded on the principle of inequality, which is the gravity in the system that makes things move — and the most pressing need now all around the world is a more egalitarian order, one that gives equal access and equal justice to all its members and produces less useless stuff and less movement of same.

for that, a whole new system of governance, production and distribution will have to be cobbled together from the remains of a shredded world order that has produced or at least not abated endless divisions, rivalries and hatred, and failed utterly in what should be the prime goal and duty of every nation and all nations collectively — égalité.

the costs of division are unmeasurably high; the costs of nations fighting nations both in trade and war, corporations fighting corporations, religions fighting religions, ethnicities fighting ethnicities, are killing the future.

we have an opportunity to free mankind from most tedious work, to free us from most disease, ignorance, prejudice, to free us from the past that clings to us so destructively, the past that retards the natural evolution to new and better paradigms and leaves us stuck on a path to destruction.

the old order is dying. we can try just endlessly fixing it but i am skeptical. the people in positions to do so are the very same people who have profited from the old system and few are willing to give up even a small modicum of privilege that all should have a better and more sustainable life, even if it means wiping out all of mankind in the bargain, themselves included. and you cannot reason with people who do not decide what to do based on objective reason or what is best for the planet.

a new order may emerge before the final calamity makes it all inutile. we can hope. it beats despair.

Sunday, 13 May 2018

ONE SIGNAL BENEATH THE NOISE

can we cut to the chase here? at the base of a pile of problems deep enough to sink the planet is the inability of humans to identify with a group containing all humans, even all animals, all living things, all things both living and non-living in the cosmos.

there was a time (being a darwinian enforces this view upon me) when identity of origin, tribe, nation, religion, caste, ethnicity, politics, school ties and country clubs must somehow have aided our survival. otherwise, why have it?

but what i have seen in my time with my eyes is that all these divisions are contrary to natural sense and honest science. there is only one story called 'life' (thank you, molecular geneticists), there is only one animal called 'human' (thank you ethnologists). acceptance of others on equal terms with ourselves is the obvious conclusion of a less narrow understanding of life and in an increasingly populous and energetic world it is becoming obvious that these past divisions that cling to so many will only bring ruin on us all.

it's time to be honest. it's time to be fair. it's time for justice, truly egalitarian justice, to become the guiding principle of all human organization. 

a friend once exclaimed to me, 'i'm so proud of my grandchildren!' my automatic response was, 'i'm proud of everyone's grandchildren.'

Friday, 13 April 2018

STORIES

everything is too simple. stories. they all want to have bad guys and good guys. it's not really like that. we all do some bad things and some good things. sometimes we don't know which is which. not that we are confused. we just really don't know. we don't think we are confused. but we are. we really get it wrong. our good things are bad. or our bad things are good.

i want to read stories like that. i'm sick of simple bullshit. if we have to write bullshit, at least we could make it subtle. complicated. surprising. i want to read stories where you and the characters aren't so damn sure who is right and who is wrong. and when.

Thursday, 12 April 2018

WHY I DON'T LIKE THE PIPELINE

the pipeline debate in british columbia and canada fails to account for what exactly this pipeline promotes — the use of tar sands oil. proponents of the pipeline say that if we don't use tar sands oil it will just be replaced by oil from saudi arabia. i wish that were true. saudi arabian oil, while we still need some during this transition period, is much cleaner, cheaper and safer to extract, refine and ship. the worst oil in the world from a pollution perspective, in both production and shipping, is tar sands oil from alberta. unfortunately, it will actually be replaced if it can be stopped, by fracking shale oil in the US, which is nearly, though not quite, as harmful.

why does the federal government in canada insist that this is good for canada and the canadian people? by any rational yardstick this is not in canada's interest. most of the ownership is american, norwegian, chinese and other. canadian ownership is actually minor. even the pipelines are not candian owned. the only thing remotely canadian about it from the getgo has been its accidental location on the earth and its labor force. well, we need massive amounts of labor right now to help us transition to wind and solar energy. this is the biggest growth industry in the world and every dollar wasted on obsolete energy production could be redirected toward that end. that might not only save alberta, and canada, it might even save the planet we ignorant humans cling to.

Wednesday, 21 March 2018

BIAS

it is sometimes difficult to see our own blindness. there is much acceptance in most of the industrialized world that guns have potential for much harm and should be highly regulated. in canada it is safe to say that much harm has been done by alcohol, not only but particularly among first-nations communities, but there is not much acceptance for the idea of highly regulating this behavior. is there some reason to ignore the possibility that regulating alcohol more highly might improve the lives of many? 

most canadians have never considered the idea that more information and education about the dangers of guns might be all that is needed. they assume regulation is necessary regardless of any information program. but they do not feel the same way about alcohol. i wonder why that is.

in assessing my own bias, i notice that i do not think most activity humans engage in should be regulated by prohibition. making illegal certain substances like alcohol and even all drugs has always seemed to me the wrong way to go. so why do i feel it is right and proper to limit public access to firearms by prohibition?

i don't know. the argument is advanced that alcohol over-consumption mainly injures oneself, whereas guns represent a threat to others. but first, others are greatly impacted and often injured by one's alcohol consumption and, second, most gun deaths are from suicide, a self-inflicted injury. 

there is more overlap between guns and alcohol (or all drugs) than is comfortable to admit.
i wonder why that is.

could it be that alcohol injury usually takes place over a protracted time and presents many opportunities for self-regulation and improvement, whereas gun injury can be sudden and instantaneous and often impossible to redress, that the sudden finality of gun injury makes it much more difficult to address with programs of education to improve awareness?

Saturday, 10 March 2018

MAN AND MOSQUITOES

man constructs himself exactly the same way mosquitoes construct themselves but he does not invent himself any more than mosquitoes do.

Saturday, 3 March 2018

ELITE POWER

elite power is the single most retarding force resisting the necessary changes in the human endeavor on earth. it is poor in most nations, bad in china, america, russia, most south american countries; it is horrible in places like syria, saudi arabia, egypt, iran and many of the countries of africa. forgive me if i have forgotten notable offenders, but you get the idea: social democracy truly needs to be tried somewhere at least once beyond scandinavia and new zealand before we give it up and look elsewhere. 

and don't talk to me about capitalist democracy, an oxymoron. private accumulation of capital is a system entirely structured around endless growth on a finite planet with a limited carrying capacity. when i was a small child there were less than two billion living humans on earth; now that i am old, there are over seven billion. do you think the small children alive today will see a growth factor in human population of four by the time they are old? do you think we are heading for a planet of twenty-five or thirty billion?

think again. and think again about elitism, including its growth-dependent private capital iteration.

Monday, 26 February 2018

LOOK UP

listening to american public discourse one would imagine there are no other countries on this planet. they never seem to look up, look out and see what other nations are doing when there is a problem america is handling badly. 

health care comes to mind. gun ownership comes to mind. there are many places on this planet where people have better health outcomes for much less expenditure, there are places very like america, in terms of history of democracy and modern technology, capitalist nations like great britain, who not only have a more efficient system of healthcare but also have very little gun violence, in schools or anywhere, including one of the saddest results of the availability of guns in the US, gun suicide.


Sunday, 25 February 2018

A LEAST HARM VIEW

beneath the superficial left-right political dynamic resides a fundamental personality difference (in varying degrees) in most people. it is reflected in one's ability to embrace change. citizen/voters are basically born with a left/right divide, and the tendency to lean left or right depending on how insecure one feels in the light of the great searchlight of change approaching has a genetic component. if you are fearful, nervous, reluctant to change your ideas and your behavior — insecure, maybe sometimes verging on the paranoid — you will reject new ideas from wherever they come, left or right, and you will consider your own needs much more than the general good. if you are more confident, secure and open in your basic personality you will consider new ideas — one would hope rationally — and be willing to accept and promote change that seems to solve emerging problems for the majority of people.

the middle, if there is one, is where the pragmatist who changes his alignment depending more on issues and perceived need than ideology exists.

in the end, darwinian nature is profoundly pragmatic and the model that best suits that understanding of life in all its forms is to think of public actions and political directions from the vantage point of the 'least harm model'. there are times when to hold to the existing way of living against threats of change is the safest path. there are times when to hold to the existing way of living is suicidal. it is up to us to think about it, to think about what is truly needed, not for ourselves alone, but for the majority and the planet.

[though debate is healthy, natural and necessary, selfishness rarely does improve society. greed is seldom good. more thoughtful and empathetic people already know this. it is time for protectionist, nationalist gun-owners, and other single-issue citizens, along with all those megalomaniacs, to stop shouting and step aside.]

Saturday, 24 February 2018

MR TRUMP AND TRUTH AND UNDERSTANDING

the salient feature to remember about mr. trump is that he is not very bright and not educated and not really intellectually curious, and his ideas about what america should do are naive in the worst sense of the word. for instance, he says if a shooter knew that a school had armed teachers in it the shooter would not enter, because shooters are cowards (who presumably want to save their own skin). this is a comical assertion; potential school shooters are, if anything, patently not rational actors acting objectively in their own interest, they are sick individuals, and many of them are suicidal (incidentally, gun suicide is one of the worst features of a country awash in weapons). it's just as likely that knowing a school has many arms in it might increase its desirability as a target to someone in the particular state of mind it takes to want to mow down your peers. it certainly is no solution to the problem, which is precisely that there are so many many guns in america.

emma gonzalez, the student who, in a reasoned and passionate and effective speech, called out mr trump, a man who defends the NRA's interest in selling guns and the politicians and citizens who support him in doing so, has done what the corrupt american political system has failed utterly to do — she has simply told the truth.

Saturday, 10 February 2018

THE OTHER NAOMI

naomi klein has been an important and useful individual in the war against reason in this world, especially the american corner of it, whose tentacles reach almost everywhere, and she has a great ally in the form of naomi oreskes, an academic with an uncommon ability to inject common sense and even a sense of humor into the struggle. her knowledge and deep understanding of the politics of special interests, along with an irrepressible optimism, is precisely what the public, the american public, and especially the american student public, needs most in this time of trumpism, a tired and not-at-all new set of assumptions that have never been less elegantly promoted or less appropriate or useful in addressing the very real existential threats that exist today.

Sunday, 4 February 2018

WHAT DO HUMANS DESERVE?

i can't imagine a more poorly managed or frightening government than the present iteration of the US. and the fact that this nation controls half the world's military and most of its nuclear weapons, along with much of the global economy, is truly incredible. the childish, narcissistic and profoundly unintelligent racist hate-monger who apparently has ultimate control of this military edifice and its potential for annihilation is a disgrace not only for the people who support him, and all americans, but for all the world's complicit people and governments.

this is a profoundly poor time for anyone anywhere to cling to a past order that is patently incapable of solving the problems of the present or the future. people of the world, if you are waiting for your government to save you, you are doomed.

are we a race that even deserves to survive? we have lately acquired so much knowledge of the natural world and its history in the cosmos, we have solved so many critical problems of continuing life on earth and we know now so much about who we are, what life is and what we must do, it should be easier than ever in our history to put earth and all its life on a sustainable path.

time to prove we can do it. and, unfortunately, it seems to depend on the poorly educated and often deliberately misled american public to anoint the process that is necessary to make it happen; another frightening thought.

APOLOGIES

sorry to be saying this and it may undo alot of what i have been trying to do in the way of objectivity, but i am afraid i face an inescapable conclusion: it does not serve the world well to have followers lead.

Thursday, 1 February 2018

NEW RULES, NEW RULERS

as gore vidal famously said a long time ago, america is ruled by the wealthy for the wealthy. any person who votes for the status quo who is not truly wealthy is voting against his own interest. 

a lot of conservative votes seem to be based on a kind of faith-based thinking, ideologically driven rather than employing a pragmatic understanding of both the global situation and the personal. this is maddening. one cannot reason with a voter who is not voting based on reason.

this was not the situation (quite) when i was young. in the US nixon proposed a negative income tax in the early seventies; in canada stanfield proposed it in the sixties. both these men were old-fashioned conservatives who just believed in going forward with changes to governance cautiously. they did not resist all change. sadly, they have little in common with what passes for conservatism in the present political climate.

looking for solutions to the present malaise, in north america at least, suggests ridding ourselves of the influence of money in elections especially and in governance more generally. whether the fault lies with individuals or corporations (who are also made of individuals) is not important to discern — the solution is the same in any case; elected representatives of the people need to represent all the people and political parties need to renounce absolute control of both the system of governance and its elections in favor of temporary coalitions based around shared beliefs in solutions to specific problems as they arise.

that we can identify these problems and so easily conceive solutions is the best, maybe the only, sign of hope for a viable and sustainable future on this declining little orb. that we seem, so far, unable to implement these changes is the worst.

Wednesday, 24 January 2018

THE TRUE ELEPHANT


how can any country in the world prosecute acts of terrorism involving a handful of people and then engage in war? the national armies of the world account for nearly a hundred per cent of the human-caused terror on this planet, yet they are legitimized even at the level of international law. 

this is truly the most enormous elephant in a not-well-hidden corner of human society and anyone with an even slightly detached and rational voice would necessarily come to the same conclusion — war is the single most destructive deadly criminal and unethical activity in the history of the world. anyone in any government waging war for any reason outside its borders should be tried as a criminal actor in a world court. any people in any government waging war against its own people for any reason should also be tried as criminal actors in a world court. 

the rights of individuals supersede the rights of nations. the rights of individual people are primary and universal, and they are the natural rights from which all other (group) rights derive. anyone, no matter in what uniform or flag they are wrapped, who harms or kills other people is a criminal and the size of the offense is the size of the damage they do to others. instead of being lauded as heroes, the people who plan and execute these large-scale atrocities should be condemned and their efforts dismantled.

how will order be kept at the scale of nations? a world body (which is already present in its nascent form) is the only organization capable of ensuring war between nations will not occur, and it should be the only organization allowed to maintain a standing army, a small mobile force to be legitimately deployed to arrest perpetrators anywhere on this globe as soon as they even attempt to acquire the technical means to wage war, or even by threat attempt to usurp the rights of others. belief in the rule of law is widely understood and there is less to be feared in this arrangement than any other we have tried on this planet, as long as men continue to attempt to dominate and harm one another.

whether we come to this arrangement after a global conflict that devastates much of the planet, or we come to this in our maturity as an ethical actor, i cannot say. that we will come to it, provided we survive as a species on a viable planet, i have no doubt.

Tuesday, 9 January 2018

CORPORATIONS (AGAIN)

corporations need to be conceived, constituted and regulated in different ways than they are presently; they need to make central the value of utility at the level of society entire instead of just at the investor level; they need to evolve around a core value of usefulness to society instead of the narrow and unethical focus on themselves. as they presently operate, they are sociopathic, even psychopathic, and that is a sickness that needs remedy. 

however, the idea of eliminating corporations is not a useful reaction to their present inutility. though they are certainly not individuals in any sense of the word, either morally, ethically or (properly) legally, they are naturally occurring manifestations of emergent organizational principles and have proven to have many practical uses that ensure they should be preserved as long as their natural life cycle permits. they just need to be regulated, and regulated by an independent collective societal voice that is not owned or regulated by them.

Sunday, 7 January 2018

GOD IN THE UNIVERSE


intelligence and understanding are global not atomistic properties of mind. they no more exist — nor are they concentrated — within a single neuron or small circuit of neurons as overseers than a termite colony building a mound has a single architect or building committee, and noone has a set of drawings or any form of plan that exists prior to and separate from the action that creates the thing. the same is true of the way entire single organisms self-assemble; there is no architect and there is no pre-existing plan, there is just the continual division into ever more complex assymetrical structures arising out of the simple actions of the simpler structure that preceded it; the plan is an integral and emerging property of the organism that is developing and is parallel to it. ditto the cosmos.

so much for god in the universe.

Monday, 1 January 2018

GENES, HISTORY AND CULTURE

there are people in the world who think that certain populations are prone to certain maladies of behavior. they say things like 'chinese people all lie and cheat' or 'italians are all loud' or iranians are all 'fundamentalists' or 'christians are all this, or jews are all that...' (i could go on). they think it is somehow bred in the bone and they apply it to whole peoples. how then would they explain the germans? after the second world war (it seems strange that we even own that phrase) the east germans were supposedly known to enthusiastically denounce each other with accusations of being anti-government; the same is true of the north koreans. how then would these people explain the fact that nothing of the sort was going on in west germany and it is not going on now in a unified germany on either side of the old divide? same for korea. these german and korean people share an identical gene pool; in fact, many of them are related across borders. the chinese people share the same gene pool with the japanese, koreans and many other people of asia; not only that, the whole world shares the same gene pool. you who are reading this, that is you and me.

it is true that different countries with different governments and different histories manifest different cultures and that some governments and some cultures are more brutal and some people more inured to a hard life, but this is historical and situational, not genetic; there is nothing unique about the individuals living there compared to individuals living elsewhere. you could find your counterpart in any country; you could find someone with opposite views of life and society in any country.

it is a dangerous form of ingroup/outgroup hostility which is more likely to be believed by people who have not known enough people from other places and cultures, or who are themselves rather fundamental in their thinking. it does not promote harmony and understanding on this tiny little orb, and promoting harmony and understanding on this tiny little orb is the only thing that will save it (and the mostly similar individuals who live on it) from oblivion. 

if you are hoping armies and power and domination of others will save you, or your country, you are hoping in vain.

Saturday, 18 November 2017

WHAT WOULD YOU DO?

conservatives in general, american conservatives in particular, are just people who are afraid of change. they are so afraid of it that rather than trying to control it, which could occasionally be useful, they just straight out resist. where this voice comes from more-or-less the sidelines there may perhaps be some utility to their actions but where they dominate and control the actions of government they are regressive, and this at a time when change is necessary to aid survival of the whole human fraternity.

but there is a second thing some conservatives indulge in and when they do they are truly dangerous — existentially dangerous — they indulge in magical thinking, they ignore, distort and lie about the very facts that decisions must reflect. and they refuse to examine examples of actions that have been tried successfully in other parts of the world outside their nation. this is more than confirmation bias. it is faith-based thinking and faith-based thinking, along with us-and-them ingroup/outgroup hostility, is ultimately fatal. if they lose their battle they are vicious, if they win we will all suffer hardship and ultimately, death.

what do you do about people like that, people who do not believe in reason or objective truth or the danger of faith-based conviction? i think lying about objectively verifiable facts and events should be a crime for every elected official, and should be prosecutable for any media attempting to spread false information. these are crimes against civilization and they are more dangerous than many of the behaviors we routinely prosecute. they are also more dangerous than any so-called restrictions on our rights to free speech that protect these false statements from censure.

Tuesday, 31 October 2017

THE LIES

the lies, the lies; i am so sick of the lies. one could make a great start on a new direction for politics if any person elected to any office had to swear to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, just as any person addressing a court of law must do. how can it be acceptable, accepted, commonplace, that when politicians speak we reflexively try to assign a sort of 'truth quotient' to everything they say? declarative statements are either true or untrue. i don't think we need to bother about what they say to their spouses, or children, or neighbors, but what they say to voters — both the ones who put them in office and the ones that tried to keep them out — that should be sacrosanct; there, the truth only should apply, and the penalties for lying (which is often only too easily proven) should be the same as for perjury; it's at least as important as that.

Wednesday, 25 October 2017

GROWTH ON A FINITE PLANET

in nature, unlimited growth without regard to its utility for the organism as a whole is called cancer. for the humans of earth to cling to a belief in a permanent state of growth model, such as the model that fundamentally underpins capitalist economies, social systems and their politics, is suicidal.

the countries and regions that evolve a more pragmatic and flexible view of systems will be the ones that survive and prosper, if indeed any can prosper in future on such a small planet; a planet which, at the moment, is dominated by mindless adherence to what amount to baseless beliefs.

alternative facts will not save you, us or anybody.

Wednesday, 18 October 2017

PROBLEM ROOTS AND ROOTS THAT NOURISH

the root of the problem with the present iteration of capitalism lies in corporate culture. some people accept as a given the arcane notion that a corporation's only obligation is to its shareholders, that the only or overriding goal of a corporation is to maximize profits. this idea is worshipped by capitalists without a sustainable strategy or social conscience as if it came down from the mount on a clay tablet. absurd. it was proffered, accepted and promoted by private capital accumulators and their apologists and it has disfigured the system and its supporters, as it is now busy ruining the culture that spawned it.


the real obligation of corporations — as it is the real obligation of all associations of humans, voluntary and involuntary — is to promote the welfare of the society entire and all the people who make up its population, together with the geographical area it controls and the biosphere within. this longterm interest can only be promoted by a sustainable best practice toward the earth and its living inhabitants of every description. and the most important element in ensuring sustainability at every scale of organization is the only, and final, excuse for any state more organized than anarchy, and that is egalitarian justice, stripped of confirmation bias and all impediments to rational thought, from whence peace and reason only can be born and nourished.

Monday, 2 October 2017

NOTES ON PRIVILEGE


there is something in social/political/economic systems that enshrines privilege. this quality of inequity has various roots in surviving custom and by conscious design and is ubiquitous. why is that? is it inherent in the human animal and therefore inevitable? i don’t know the answer. i have tried to observe not only humans but also other animals of our planet, without conclusive results, but tentatively i would have to say that i think such a condition is most likely evolutionarily designed, that it is rooted in the species’ common urge to survive and procreate.

ideas, like individuals, also compete. one idea that seems to run against the current is the idea of limiting ideas that compete with present mores. much effort is given to thwarting new thought by those who administer and profit from present assumptions and practices. this seemingly contrary behavior may endure because it promotes stability at the expense of adaptability, that change is in itself dangerous and needs to be controlled for the safety of the species. or it might endure simply because some are selfish and concerned more with their own survival, comfort and pleasure than their society in total. in my experience i would have to say the latter reason is supported by more evidence, though even if true it may have ineluctably produced increased fitness.


whether anything can be done to effectively make cooperation, more than competition, a fundamental first principle in the minds of the peoples of earth i am not sure, though i do think that, to the degree humans have survived to dominate the planet, that domination is not largely the result of competition, unbridled or otherwise, but owes its success much more to the continuing (and growing) influence of cooperation.

AAH, GIVE ME SCIENCE

there is more philosophy implied in molecular genetics and the study of animal behavior than there is in hemingway, joyce or faulkner and, among others, kant, hegel and especially, freud.

Sunday, 23 July 2017

FERRON

i went to a ferron concert on saturna island last night. she is a great feeler and thinker and singer about life, and more particularly the life she has lived, an uncomfortable life. this life lies beside a knife-edge that separates it from the life of someone very comfortable in her own skin, and it is from the sharp and dangerous edge of this knife that her best thoughts and songs emanate; a singular, original and very beautiful experience for anyone lucky enough to be within earshot.

Monday, 10 July 2017

DON'T ASK

i am walking in wild grass heavy with spiky seedtops
i don't ask the grass 'why did you decide to be grass?'
there is a sleek robin there perched on a stick looking smoothly beautiful
i don't ask the robin 'why did you decide to be a robin?'
there is me thinking these words.

Saturday, 17 June 2017

WRITING LIKE HEMINGWAY

i made my little sanctuary. it was beautiful in the sun. it was beautiful in the wind. it was beautiful in the mist and fog and drizzle and rain, my little sanctuary. it was snug and it suited me and i suited it. i made it myself and it suited me.

Monday, 15 May 2017

APPROPRIATION OF VOICE

let me add a couple of cents worth of support for the poor beleagured writers of canada who are enduring an infection that is silly and stupid — appropriation of voice is an incredible nod to narrow tribal thinking at a time in history when we know so much more. i have alot in common with fruit flies. i share emotions with honeybees and fish and all animals. i share affection like slugs, and like slugs i remember these experiences in the same way, with the same brain processes. how big a stretch do you think it is to write about a woman if you are a man? to write about an old man if you are young? why aren't we being ostracised for doing that? why aren't we being ostracised for any fiction? i'll tell you why: fiction is just another tool for getting at the truth, as is imagination, empathy, mirror neurons, group contagion and other manifestations of social thought, dangerous or not.

loosen up, guys, and have a look over your shoulder — you are on the wrong side of history, truth, knowledge and progress.

Saturday, 13 May 2017

CURIOUS

there is a curious mixture of sense and nonsense on the radio news that upon reflection i have concluded is a fair typification of the human condition. mixed with news of mr trump these days, in ever smaller proportion, are other news items: of cyberhacking — this time data ransom attacks around the world —  from the vatican, of miracle sightings and canonization, of trump supporters defending their man, to name a few, along with reports of saudi princesses abusing other humans compelled to serve them and chicago mayors all serving jailtime. 

wait a minute; where is the good stuff? come to think of it, it may not be much of a mixture after all. the poor well-fed well-informed well-cared for beleaguered literate middleclass citizen must be barely clinging to life these days. how terrifying.

Tuesday, 2 May 2017

COMPETITION VS COOPERATION

why are all sports competitive? there didn't get to be seven billion humans on the planet because we are good at competition, lots of failed animals failed while competing with their own kind; more it was because we learned to cooperate. i don't think it takes alot of imagination to conjure up ways people can play a game toward a higher score by means of better cooperation — games where everyone playing is essentially on the same team and cooperation is rewarded, as it so often is in life. 

the highly competitive among us are and always have been mostly doing things that make life better for themselves, and often, much tougher for others. is that really still so valuable to us now, now that what threatens us is not lack of fitness but lack of cohesion?

fighting fires is all about cooperation; the enemy is not a person. the team wins if they can, but there is really no opponent who loses, the fire being a phenomenon without a will. 

soon the earth will be on fire. what do you think can save it for the creatures? competition?

i don't think so.

Thursday, 9 March 2017

NAMING IT

the healthcare debate in the US is already tiresome. i hear alot of talk from rightwing politicians who speak for all the world like ideologues. the problem is not only that they are not truthful in anything they say, not only that they abandon pragmatism as well as truth, not only that their agenda is (slightly) hidden from a naive constituency, the real problem is that their ideas are stupid, and if allowed to prevail will soon hurt the people they profess to represent (as opposed to the people they truly represent, of course).

really, we should call them idiotlogues, because that is what they are.

Friday, 10 February 2017

DANGEROUS IDEAS

when i was a young kid, a little catholic kid, i was told by my perfectly sweet shy mother what a shame it was that my friends, who were mostly protestant (along with a jew or two), would never get into heaven. i couldn't believe what she was saying and as was my habit i called her on it. but to her it was a matter of faith, and authority, and one did not question one's faith, or authority in general. she also believed in experts, believed they somehow had a direct link with the truth.

these are dangerous ideas. Us and Them is the most dangerous idea on the present planet earth and the world's only military superpower has just installed at the helm an Us and Them damagogue of epic proportions, who is surrounding himself with others just like him.

this does not bode well for anybody. it is way past time for people to stop rooting for themselves, in any guise, and start rooting for the survival of the planet.

BIAS

humans have frailties that make them vulnerable to extinction and one of the most problematic is confirmation bias. believing that your country, your religion, your city, state or region, your sex, color, generation, even your hockey team, is better than others is just another way of believing you are better than others. and that is a fundamental problem for the species. 

Thursday, 9 February 2017

LATE TO THE PARTY

there is a fundamental struggle going on in america which i think could have been resolved about five hundred years ago; that is the struggle for cultural dominance between religion and the scientific method. this debate has been resolved most successfully in europe and parts of the east, and it leaves america deeply late to the party. 

this is dangerous; when the world's only military superpower is embedded in a fractured and still unevolved ethos it will be tempting for them to continue to enforce domination in world affairs by increasingly bellicose military means. 

this is an existential threat to them and the world entire. if americans cannot step up to the reality bar quickly, President Loser, the new demagogue of hate installed in the whitehouse, will have to be stopped by people outside its borders, and that is a threat to the planet of epic proportions.

Wednesday, 8 February 2017

GAMES PEOPLE PLAY

the people who live within the world of finance are addicted to a game. it is not a game of survival against the elements of the cosmos that are hostile to life, it is not a game of self-reliance or belonging in a global enterprise — what i would label the real games of life — more it is a game like a boardgame. i wish it weren't so, but i am afraid the tired old game they insist on continuing to play is the depression-era game of Monopoly, a game whose ideas and principles were long ago, at least morally, discredited. and like the game, this modern capitalist system will end just as surely as the game of Monopoly ends, and in precisely the same way, when one combatant has acquired all the capital and there is noone else left standing with anything to lose. 

and like people in all places through all time, when there is nothing left to lose, people get ugly.

Sunday, 5 February 2017

PRESIDENT LOSER

mr trump is forgetting the first principle of elected office — try not to piss off the people. let's hope it continues. he is a dangerous fascist racist whose constituency is not now and has never been the people, except in the sense of whom to fool, his constituency is corporations and elites around the world.






Tuesday, 31 January 2017

EARTH MODEL 2003


(from a talk given at a writers' night at the Saturna Café November 02 )

First I would like to erect a model of an earth worthy of our children— second to consider how our current situation differs from that model—third to suggest how our present sorry path can be deflected toward it.

THE MODEL
The place I would like to see my children live in is free of intimidation destruction and murder— it is free of any institutional inequality between individuals and also free of any semblance of group rights or privilege including rights of corporations or religions or political parties and other non-individual entities presently treated as individuals under the law.

In this imagined place the rights of individuals (the only human rights) are enshrined in international law without regard to sovereignty of nations and enforced by the United Nations. Earth itself and the biosphere are also protected by international law which supersedes all regional and national laws. The right to bear arms is restricted to the UN. All weapons of mass destruction— including and especially armed forces— are prohibited to any group smaller than that.

No other laws beyond individual, earth and biosphere rights are declared or enforced by the UN. Regional cultural and ethnic uniqueness are matters of individual choice as are methods of local governance or absence of governance provided international laws are not violated by custom or in practice. (In adjudicating these customs and practices there is no escaping the conclusion that any form of institutionalized privilege is inimical to justice. And justice not peace is always the goal and in fact is the only path to lasting peace.)

There is no attempt at enforced homogeneity. Differences that do not result in institutional inequality are tolerated. The free exchange of ideas is encouraged. With the free movement of people care to control the rate of flow at least initially and for a period allowing the peaceful and non-disruptive movement of individuals is needed. There should be no destabilizing and hence destructive shift of population but rather a gradual diminution of regional inequities through transfer payments such as exist in the European Union and Canada. This will have a retarding influence on migration for most people, who naturally love their birthplace.

The enforcement of rights by the UN— including the free right to life health and education— includes the UN’s right to taxation of nations according to ability to pay and of individuals worldwide without regard to nationality. This will necessarily involve some arbitrary limits on the growing disparity of wealth among the world’s regions as well as its individuals.

This means that the wealthy will not continue to get wealthier but ultimately with the end of military expenditures and costs of reconstruction no person anywhere will ever be forced to live in jeopardy. This does not mean that charity will be forgotten as long as inequities persist but that no lives will be ultimately dependent on it.

If this seems utopian so be it. It is obtainable when once the mighty have been subsumed in the family of mankind. To this end the Thoreau-Gandhi-King ethic of non-violent non-cooperation has proved itself more powerful than propaganda and armies combined and is the only technique necessary— or in my view even possible.

THE PRESENT
Preaching any war of any description for any purpose intended to make peace is doomed by definition— war is not peace. The idea that Mr. Bush is going to Iraq to give the people freedom ignores the obvious, that the first right of any peope would of course be freedom from invasion.

The UN has already fashioned an international bill of human rights more than fifty years ago. It needs the ability to enforce these rights not only between nations but internally within nations without regard to custom or status either historical or by reason of power and wealth. And its charter already expressly forbids acts of aggression by states upon other states, which it also needs the ability to enforce either by arms or preferably by international isolation of responsible leaders. This prohibition should be widened to include any occupation by any foreign power either militarily or by any other means of intimidation or threat, with the sole exception of the UN itself.

No nation today, least of all the United States, could exist in its present form without the cooperation, willing or otherwise, of other nations. The power of non-cooperation should not be doubted. The United States once isolated from its markets, for arms especially, would experience rapid economic decline more certainly than if it were deterred by force (which in any case could prove fatal to all). The US economy and standard of living depend on arms exports and control of oil. This requires a climate of fear and conflict to continue. Peace, no matter how they posture as a peace-loving nation, is inimical to the whole American enterprise— a terrible predicament for them and indeed the whole world— and they are going to need outside help in the form of overt pressure in order to restructure and thence reduce the insecurity of the world, including themselves. In this our interests are the same no matter how differently perceived.

The world must help the US help itself. It must be weaned from this dependence on arms and armies— on intimidation destruction and murder— and the crime of murder, which is the ultimate denial of individual rights, cannot be suspended just because some leader(s) declares a military action a ‘war’. It also must be made an international crime of the most serious magnitude to profit from violence in any way at any scale— another task for the world court.

What are the rights of war? And where does the human (animal) notion of rights of any kind originate? I have a strong life-long feeling that I inherently own the right to my own life. I think all rights flow from that primary feeling. If this is true then individual rights, being the origin of all rights, must remain sacrosanct — and an idea like immunity from prosecution for any persons on the earth is an affront to all. The right of any person or nation to make war whether on its own citizens or others must be eliminated as individual reprisal has been eliminated between citizens under the rule of law within nations.

DEFLECTING THE PATH
The first step we must take in deflecting the current destructive path of history toward a model of equanimity is to strengthen the UN and to enshrine the Individual Bill of Rights in international law, at the same time giving the UN the sole power to enforce it — and only it — over the whole of the globe. We must wean nations gradually of absolute sovereignty, starting with adoption of the world court jurisdiction as the world entire and continuing with granting the UN the power of taxation, then on to the gradual lock-stepped dismantling of all the nations’ armed forces in favor of a small highly mobile UN peacekeeping and peacemaking force of conventional arms comprised of small representative forces from a majority of willing nations.

As a first step in reducing the world’s national armies, the right to conduct military operations should be restricted to the territory legally owned by each nation, including the area of its fishing rights, up to the first two hundred miles of surrounding ocean where shoreline exists without conflicting claims and along some midpoint between nations where jurisdiction might otherwise overlap. This would allow for a less disruptive shift in internal structures of power, including both political and economic power, within nations. Ultimately, the only forces in the world that will be legitimately mobile will be UN forces.

No nation can seriously call its military forces defense forces which is involved in invasion or occupation of any other nation on earth. Those are offensive actions, in both senses of the word. And how long can it take for all the world’s peoples to recognize that if no-one can leave the home territory there can be literally no-one to defend against except the UN, which will have such constraints against its actions as to be a most unlikely adversary. In any event, this position of allowing national forces as long as they stay home will be only a transient structure, and as the expense of keeping large forces will be a serious detriment to economic participation in a global economy, should die of its own weight, if in fact democracy is a workable system of governance.

This fundamental change in power will necessarily involve restructuring the UN so that veto status is eliminated and voting power reflects population with a qualified majority along the lines of the new EU constitution (with perhaps the addition of a ‘taxation’ factor). It should be understood that only nations in good standing would be accorded any vote at all and that to remain in good standing nations must comply with all UN qualified majority decisions and pay their taxes. This means the end of international unilateralism.

In game theory ‘tit for tat’ works out to be the cleanest simplest and most effective strategy of cooperation. Perhaps some modified less destructive version of that will prove useful in developing protocols for the new UN. But whatever system of control evolves it will have to focus mainly on national governments. They have done most of the killing and suppressing of rights throughout history and certainly lack any claim to legitimacy however they have arrived and for however long they have ruled. Only individuals have an inherent right to protection under international law— every group is suspect that is smaller than mankind and must prove itself worthy of international support by its egalitarianism and its actions.

Even mankind is too small a group. The biosphere— earth itself— is vital. The goal is to sustain life on earth indefinitely— not for one species or nation or region or generation but for all.

EPILOGUE 19 MARCH 2003 (after the invasion of Iraq)
I remain skeptical that these features of a world government can in fact be implemented without a possibly cataclysmic confrontation among the world’s nations— a confrontation that it is not at all clear we can survive. But whether this vision of our world will be brought about gradually through diplomacy or suddenly in the aftermath of a deadly war that some manage to survive, I also have no doubt that by the beginning of the next century if any of our progeny do indeed still exist they will live under the auspices of some form of world democracy, and absolute sovereignty with its concomitant right to bear arms will be a relic of history.


That is the real business of the twenty-first century. It is time we got down to business.

(from 2007) THE UNITED CITIZENS OF EARTH

There is a fundamental problem with the United Nations and that is the recognition of sovereignty of nations above the rights of individuals. This has effectively eliminated the possibility of the UN ever bringing justice to all the world’s people and that effectively eliminates the possibility of ever bringing peace. The United Nations was the start, and the only possible start, of the formation of a true world government and it has gone as far as it can go within the constraints of its original charter. It is time for a new or radically altered body— it is time to make the individual the basis for rights and obligations under the world body. It is time for the UN to become the United Citizens of Earth.
To make this fundamental shift a reality does not mean the elimination of nations. They are a (sometimes) legitimate form of regional government and many things presently under the control of nations can best be determined at that scale. Similarly, the division of powers within nations into smaller regional areas, even down to cities and towns and rural areas, each with its own government controlling issues that affect its citizens at that scale, is also workable. What is needed is a new definition of ultimate rights. Ultimate rights must originate with the individual and migrate upward, not in a hierarchy but a circle, so that the individual is not only closest to the most local governance but on his other side to the most global governance. The individual becomes the point on the circle from which all other rights emanate.

In practice, the defense of the individual’s rights, including and especially his life, would be the joint responsibility of the entire circle of governance and would remain paramount. Under this structure, whatever threatened the rights and life of the individual would be protected by other bodies of the circle and if one member of the circle was threatening those rights it would be the obligation of other members to protect them from the threat. In this arrangement, the exisiting practice of local governments being subject to regional control and regional governments being subject to national control would be extended to include national governments being subject to world control.

In nations at present local laws are similarly subject to regional laws and regional laws are subject to national laws. This hierarchy too must be extended to global laws, perhaps limited to individual and biosphere rights, which will supercede all national laws. And an international justice system whose jurisdiction is the entire globe must be part of any new charter.

This may sound simple, even obvious, but it will be an enormous struggle of the will of the people everywhere to prevail and bring to heel those powerful individuals within national governments that have been accustomed to controlling the power of societies, both economic and military.

Once accomplished, it will become apparent that while local police forces may maintain civil order in towns, cities, states and nations under the rule of law, none of these police forces will have any jurisdiction outside their geographic areas. The same must apply to so-called armies kept by nations. No national army should have any legal right to act in or occupy any territory not legally its own, no matter what the pretext. Only the army of the United Citizens would have legitimacy over the entire globe, and then only to defend the rights of individuals and biosphere threatened by national forces within or between nations. National armies would effectively be police forces employed only to prevent violations of rights not protected by more regional bodies, never to gain territory or expand influence, either political or economic. And national territorial boundaries in particular could only legitimately be altered by negotiations ratified by majority decisions of the world body in a full and free vote.

Failing this, global problems such as atmospheric warming and the newly expanding nuclear threat cannot be effectively resisted. The last decade has seen the increased militarism of powerful nations emerge, including the threat of widening the arena to include the space above our atmosphere. This is likely to be a greater threat to us in the near future than even global warming, and like global warming its pace is accelerating.

If we can’t restrain the powerful individuals in powerful nations I have no doubt we will all die together and the meek who inherit the earth will turn out to be cockroaches or viruses. What a failed experiment we will have turned out to be— what an epitaph written of us all.

The prospect of inaction or endless fractional infighting in the cause of protecting privilege is very real and the most likely impediment to survival. Whether the instrument of our demise is global warming or a nuclear cataclysm, or some other unforseen problem, the cause of our demise will have ultimately been the same— the inability of individuals to recognize the equal rights of all and to forego the domination of others.


Sunday, 29 January 2017

IGNORANT AMERICA

this is the face of ignorant america. the mean, the cruel, the degenerate are inspired by this public display of sociopathy. if the american right wing wants to survive their demagogue and not be decimated by history, they must stop the man, stop supporting the man, stop enabling the man, not in time for the next elections in four years, nor in two years, not tomorrow, but now.

Sunday, 8 January 2017

NATION-STATE


the theme of the new book i have begun is to me more fundamental than global warming or overpopulation. it is time to redefine and rejustify the concept of the nation-state:

there is only one excuse and one rationale for anything beyond anarchy as an organizing principle of humans and that is the pursuit of justice. peace is not a goal. peace is the natural outcome of reciprocal justice and unless and until that becomes the bounding principle of every state on this earth and every action taken in the name of that state, we humans of earth will have failed to secure a viable future.

which means to say, pretty much, since the idea that states all over the world will somehow reform themselves without coercion is without evidence, we are likely doomed as a species unless a world government can emerge with controlling oversight of nation-states.

Monday, 2 January 2017

HOLLYWOOD AND THE TAR SANDS

i think it's time the great hollywood blockbuster film took its rightful place beside the tar sands of alberta. they are both huge blights on our planet and our culture, sucking the air (and the carbon budget) out of the room of their respective fields of human endeavor and making it difficult for more worthy projects to replace them.

Sunday, 11 December 2016

CLINGING TO FAILED IDEAS

the united states suffers from institutionalized ignorance and it is endemic. as a nation they cling to a capitalist-centered world view, a winner-take-all ethic and a profoundly unempathetic attitude toward other people, not only of the world but within their own country. like other unevolved nations they still rely on first-past-the-post elections, a two-party system which cannot represent the views of many of its diverse citizens, and control of government at every level by moneyed interests. 

this regrettable situation will be exacerbated by the newly elected government and those who still seek to present optimistic scenarios or caution against despair are guilty of wilful blindness. it will be bad. it will hurt americans and it will hurt us all. and by withholding its undeniable power to assist in solving the existential threats both to itself and the planet, the united states will be materially responsible for its collapse, if it should indeed come to that.

though i hear ringing in my ears, 'be careful what you wish for,' i do think it is past time for a world governing body to wrest control of world-scale issues from the hands of regional interests.

Wednesday, 30 November 2016

OSTRICHES

what is it about canadian politicians that they so resemble ostriches, who put their heads in the sand when threatened with a difficult situation? the sand these politicians are burying their heads in is the tar sands and they are not going to come out of it looking clean and spiffy. 

the only practical solution to canada's contribution in opposing the encroaching devastation of climate change (and the tar sands are the biggest single canadian contributor to our terrible, sasquatch-sized footprint) is the complete cessation of alberta's mining of these tar sands.

so why are we spending treasure to increase the destructive flow of bitumen from this terrible foreign-controlled site that we will someday soon have to start trying to distance ourselves from? this is not about jobs, pipelines don't add significant jobs for the size of the capital investment, this is unneeded and unwanted infrastructure that is running against the stream of not only history but also science, and it is purely based on the inability of a privileged segment of the population to admit that their privilege is based on the destruction of our future, all our futures, their own included. getting off the tar sands will require a lot of new green energy infrastructure, which really is much more labor-intense and will result in many more good, technical as well as construction jobs, than any pipeline proposal.

the oligarchs do not speak for us, the great majority of humans, nor for the other life of earth. this is the sickest short-sided stupidity at precisely the moment in the history of the exploitation of earth by modern humans when better ways are actually finally clear to us. we know what path we have to take. why do we let shortsighted, selfish and callous sociopaths continue to dominate the large-scale efforts of man? if they keep on, you will soon be saying goodbye and good riddance to capitalism in all its forms, the good with the bad. times are going to quickly overtake us. while we fiddle with corrupt political and capital systems, trimming the edges and trying to make them look like something they are not and never have been, the planet burns.

Monday, 10 October 2016

THIS NADINE GORDIMER

this nadine gordimer knows what a novel is. knows what structure is. knows what meaning to chase down, to capture, knows the shape of the trap that will snare it.

one reads The Pickup thinking it like a Y; two people from different places brought accidentally together, who go on living as one complicated strand made of two, the stem of the Y. but it is not a Y. it is an X. and the author has known it and known where it goes and what she is after nailing to the earth, to the page, and she does nail it, artfully, carefully, letting out just enough at every turn, to cause that wonderful novelistic thing —— the inevitable surprise.

you think you know, even for quite a time, until coming up from underneath there is emerging another knowing, the right one this time, to surprise you. this woman born of, emerging from, a cold materialistic world of privilege, which values privilege over justice, who seeks the enveloping warmth of family. this man born of family, emerging from a stifling, formal, inflexible set of meanings and imperatives that yet better values human warmth and care, though in poverty, who seeks the expanding potential of success unbridled, of privilege, security, worldliness, even wealth — everything he sees embodied in her. everything that she wishes to abandon in favor of the family he seeks to abandon — how can it be anything but a perfect X?

first with her friends at the L A café and then with his relatives in africa, she has sought the enclosing warmth of a family she has never known. he has sought a kind of privilege he has heard of but never known. they have been forced by the author to confront one another, and to confront the ideas they each represent. how inevitable. how perfect.

like life in a crystal glass, we get to see it clearly, in the clarity of the novelist's singular unswerving vision.

if life were as visible as this we would never need novels.